| Making little minds chirp alike. HBO’s “Big Little Lies” (Fair Use) |
In the second season of HBO’s “Big Little Lies,” Meryl Streep plays an ice cold, judgmental, baldly acid mother in law with an unapologetically shallow value system. (They let her play herself, in other words.) Along the way, we get to see how the children of Monterrey, California are taught to be good world citizens. In this clip, they are encouraged to swear off pork, courtesy of a Charlotte-the-spider intent on teaching sustainability. Who knew that’s what she and Wilbur the pig were up to all along??
So when I first saw this, and got a little sick, I couldn’t identify precisely the source of my nausea. The science is weird, of course. When someone observes that it takes a thousand gallons of water (20 showers!) to get a single pound of sausage, are they contending that water vanishes from the universe, never to be seen again? Sometimes I think hard core environmentalists don’t have the slightest appreciation for the sustainability of nature itself. Matter is in constant transformation. Today’s cow pie is tomorrow’s sun flower. This year’s idiot progressive teacher is next century’s nice green turf.
But when I re-watched this clip again, the real big chill would have to be the choral answers. When I was a kid, the teacher asked for raised hands and allowed a few wrong answers, in sequence, before some kid (usually me or Brian Mittman), got to shine. The questions were about generally acknowledged fact, or plot points in the story we were reading. If there was room for a difference of opinion, we were encouraged to have an exchange of ideas.
Ponder today’s reality: kids get to be as slow and as dumb as their teachers, and they better wait for everyone in the room to get it wrong at the same time, comrades.
Warning, folks: group think of this sort is the kind of thing that makes for future Chernobyls — an HBO series actually worth watching.
This reminds me of when my oldest son was in the 3rd grade. At dinner one night, he told us about an assignment they had at school that day. The teacher read a story to the students after lunch about a man who went into the woods to cut down a tree, but tired from the morning’s chores, he first sat down leaning against the tree and fell asleep with his ax next to him. He awoke a short time later to find the animals in the forest all around him. They begged him not to cut down the tree, explaining that for some it was their home, for others it provided food, and for still others, it gave shade or was a scratching post. So, the man went home without cutting down the tree. The assignment was for the students to write how the story made them feel.
I asked my son if he wrote that the story made him sad. He asked why would it. I then explained that the man was likely not cutting the tree down for fun; no doubt his family needed wood to heat their home, to cook their food, or to build something, and now they had to do without. I then said in jest that if the man wanted to be compassionate, he would have killed the animals who lived in the tree so they would not be homeless, cut down the tree, and used the wood to cook the animals so his family could eat. My son laughed, but I’d made my point.
Liberalism is all about feeling good without taking into account the practical consequences. And therein lies the rub…
That’s why their side is generally better at chanting than ours.